Arrogance: the most lethal trait for CEOs

Overview

The difference between confidence and arrogance is often difficult to detect in CEOs during an interview process.  This unfortunate reality plagues Boards since arrogance is, in my view, the single most dangerous trait for a private equity-backed CEO.  Let’s consider all of the implications of an arrogant leader.

They usually:

  • Don’t welcome counsel and may not readily accept guidance from the Board
  • Have difficulty evolving and improving making them less adaptable
  • Exhibit artificially low levels of respect for the competition making them susceptible to market share losses
  • Underestimate the difficulty of challenges
  • Struggle with self-assessments and therefore self-improvement
  • Become susceptible to corner cutting believing their own ability can make the difference
  • Find it challenging to recruit A-players
  • Don’t respond well to setbacks
  • Hesitate to push accolades out to their teams
  • Struggle mightily with leadership

Confidence (plus Wisdom) is a Must

In my expeirence, the winning recipe involves CEOs who possess exceptionally high levels of confidence, gorunded in wisdom and humility.

Confidence drives:

  • Setting and achieving stretch goals
  • A winning and competitive culture
  • The ability to respond to setbacks

For the full power of confidence to be released it must be grounded in humility and empathy…and powered by wisdom.

Assessing the Difference

If you know the tells, arrogance can be identified during an interview process. Look for arrogant signals such as:

  • A lack of true self esteem
  • Discomfort when answering questions about mistakes and lessons learned
  • Lower levels of empathy
  • A personal career agenda rather than one focused on the greater good of the business and investors
  • An inability to articulate a personal development plan for continuous learning
  • A lack of unwavering ownership of all outcomes

Pay close attention whe referencing a CEO.  Comments from the team that reported to your CEO candidate will provide valuable insight.

Wisdom

Pay close attention to your perception of each CEO candidate’s general levels of wisdom.  Wisdom and arrogance are essentially mutually exclusive so ample wisdom is a very good thing…in more ways than one.  A private eqiuty Board’s ability to assess wisdom is often instinctual so search commitee memebers must listen to their inner voice – it will usually steer Boards in the right direction, at least in terms of evaluating wisdom.

Conclusion

Boards should veiw arrogance as a fast-lane to a hiring mistake.  Instead, Boards should prize supremely confident candidates while also assessing for humility, empathy and – most of all – wisdom.

 

 

Written by Rob Huxtable

Rob is a recognized expert on the topic of private equity CEO performance and recruitment. He is Founder & Principal of PrivateEquityCEO.com. He is also Managing Partner of Integis which is the nation’s leading search firm focused exclusively on the private equity-backed, middle market.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s